29 Comments
User's avatar
Pam Wilkinson's avatar

Loved this, Rona. I’m sorry you have carried this around for so long.

I have battled anxiety and depression all my life.

My Grade 2 teacher’s report card comment,

“Pammy is a moody child and I wish she would keep her garbage out of the aisles.”

Hospitalized twice in my late twenties. When the SSRI drugs arrived, I was in my forties and they worked. Losing my father and two sisters has been a challenge. I get lost in that sometimes and it takes work and Simon to pull me up.

I too have found sheer bliss and amazement on my walks with him.

Thanks for this.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Oh, Pam. That teacher. "Garbage" in the aisles, indeed. I am so sorry. Wishing you many more lovely rambles with sweet Simon.

Expand full comment
Pam Wilkinson's avatar

If she had investigated the change in behaviour from the previous year she might have correctly assumed there was a problem on the home front.

I started school at 4 so I was only 6 turning 7.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Adults can be so terribly dense about the children in their care.

Expand full comment
Ariel T. Friesner's avatar

My second grade teacher, Miss Frané, was unbelievably cruel to me for no reason. What trash did you put out in the walkway?

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

How terribly hard for little you. Some teachers should have chosen a different profession.

Expand full comment
Andi Penner's avatar

Dear Rona: In my poetry folder (.docx drafts-in-progress), I have a poem I first titled, "A Dance to the End of Depression," when I scribbled it in my journal in 1991. Since then, it has undergone much transformation, as have I. Now it exists as "Act I" of a poem in three short acts. Thank you for reminding me to revisit it, revise it, edit it, and publish it. One of the lines is, "She dances for generations." We have so many dance partners.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

What’s occurred to me has often occurred to someone else, and that’s a good thing. Originality is overrated.

Expand full comment
Leanne Fournier's avatar

Thank you for this lovely gift Rona. I am so happy you're here and look forward to reading more! The woman you describe is such a powerful example of the many faces of depression and the fact that we often never know someone's struggles or story. Thanks again for this!

Expand full comment
Michelle Dowd's avatar

I love your beautiful Casey!

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Light of our lives.

Expand full comment
Holly Starley's avatar

Thank you for sharing this beacon in the dark.

I have found in recent years a gift I wasn't aware (or maybe able, full stop) to reach for in my younger years. It's the knowing that I won't feel exactly as I do now tomorrow. This knowledge is solace in that it makes me more able, more often to sit with what is without feeling compelled to try and fix it or guilty because I can't.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Holly, what a wonderful and useful insight. Of course, it cuts both ways: You won't always feel as sparkly as you do at your best, so you're wise to savor the brilliance and fix it in your memory like a blaze on a trail.

Expand full comment
Holly Starley's avatar

Ah, truth.

Expand full comment
Eileen Vorbach Collins's avatar

Another one that hits so close to home. When I asked myself that question about how many people in my circle have lost someone to suicide I didn't bother to count. Thank you, Rona, for writing so openly about what is not simply "the common cold of mental illness."

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Thank goodness that metaphor is just about gone.

Expand full comment
JoyofWriting's avatar

Pete Seeger is the most cheerful musician, I find.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

He radiated hope for the world.

Expand full comment
Gail Armand's avatar

I read your words hoping for unsmudged glass to the unremitting weeping of others. I have felt depression in the long ago, replaced at the time by multiple bad decisions -anything to climb out of the abyss. Time helped. Trudging along the same well worn paths eventually I found the courage to stray into a place where I found agency. I think that is the term for recognizing one’s unique abilities to cope.

Casey does that for you, stopping to peruse the doggy landscape and thereby showing you his world. Through his shared being and purpose light comes in.

I think I would welcome conversation about this, give and take, ruminating on what is said. Although I have personally experienced depression, it is still so dark in my mind I cannot take it in on any level. Maybe I am afraid to feel it again.

There are two people in a sort of medium circle in my mattering now who are suffering and one who is looking straight at the loss of her daughter to brain cancer. There are my own daughters who insistently drag me into their darkest places as our primary interaction and are outraged that I cannot bring them out. There is mental illness depression and the dark night of the soul when one’s most significant other is gone. Both are unfathomable.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

What a lot of anguish surrounds you, Gail. Depression can be contagious, and loss can bring it on. I am particularly saddened for your daughters and the impact of their affliction on you. Nobody can bring anybody out of depression, although a good therapist can do a world of good.

Expand full comment
Kim Pittaway's avatar

Terrific post, Rona, and I love the phrase "joyful melancholic." Happy to see you writing here regularly!

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Means a lot, Kim. I've been recommending your posts on writing.

Expand full comment
Debra's avatar

A powerful read this morning and one I will return to. When I lived in the city, walking the one and a half miles to my studio engaged all the senses and pulled me out of whatever state of mind I was in-though sometimes city scenes could also be depressing. Now, retired in the PNW, nature centers me as I cannot avoid looking out my windows at the beauty of the mountains. I am still grappling with what to do at 2 a.m. when the world events keep me awake. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Hanna McElroy's avatar

Rona, beautiful. I've never been depressed, but have had anxiety my whole life, a close cousin, and found relief with medication five years ago, and of course with my angel Newfie Freya. But my mum's bouts of depression were debilitating for the family, and still haunt me.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Your mother could radiate pleasure and grace, but I was aware of her fragility. Depression infects the whole family. A person in despair is a bottomless pit.

Expand full comment
Gail Armand's avatar

So true

Expand full comment
Jane O' Hara's avatar

Beautiful. Powerful. Moving.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Thank you, Jane. Writing this one took a while.

Expand full comment
Michelle Dowd's avatar

I love your beautiful Casey!

Expand full comment